← Surgical Journal

Clinical reflection / 01

“Will his eye
be saved?”

“Iski aankh toh bach jaegi na?”
A father's question, and the responsibility behind an answer.

Dr Bhushan Kathuria3 minute read

A young boy faced another operation after a tumour had returned. For the surgical team, the discussion involved disease, previous treatment and difficult anatomy. For his father, everything came together in one question: “Will his eye be saved?”

It was a short question carrying a much longer future. A parent was thinking about the child who would return home, go to school and grow up. The operation mattered because of the life beyond it.

Hope needs an honest answer

The wish to preserve the eye was central to the discussion. Yet wanting an outcome and being able to promise it are different things. The responsibility was to explain what we hoped to achieve, what might make it difficult and what could remain uncertain.

Such conversations are part of surgical care. A family needs to understand the intention behind an operation, as well as the limits of what an operation can offer. Compassion does not require certainty; it requires attention and honesty.

What does preservation mean?

For me, the father's question reached beyond keeping an anatomical structure. It brought vision, comfort, appearance and the child's future into the conversation. These concerns belonged alongside the effort to treat the disease.

Previously treated anatomy made the operation demanding. The account recorded here describes preservation of the eye and early postoperative function. That early observation was meaningful, but it could not answer every question about the years ahead.

The story continues after surgery

Relief after an operation is real. It is also only one moment in a longer course of recovery and follow-up. An encouraging early result should not be mistaken for a final outcome or a claim of cure.

What stays with me, and what I still need to learn from, is the father's question. It reminds me to listen for the life a family is trying to protect behind the treatment they are asking about. Surgical precision matters; so does remembering why that precision matters to the person in front of us.

More books and writing →